Sunday, May 10, 2015

Anti-Bias Activity

I chose this activity because I love to cook. If I can incorporate one of my favorite things to do with teaching children about different cultures, it’s a win-win! The activity I chose is called “Family Foods” and it involves a parent coming in and teaching the children a little bit about where they are from, and having the children make a recipe from their home.

Family Foods:
Themes- families, my people
Objectives- recognize and celebrate one’s own diet and style of eating
                     -Identify with one’s own culture
                     -Share one’s own culture with others
Materials- Ingredients and cooking utensils will depend on the recipe.
Description- Ask parents to share one of their family’s favorite recipes from their home culture. Invite the parent into the class to prepare the recipe with the children. You could even schedule a “Favorite Family Food” cooking experience each week.
                Get the recipe from the parents ahead of time. Purchase the ingredients. Buy enough so that children can explore the raw ingredients. Introduce the parent and cooking activity at group time. Ask the parent to show the children some of the ingredients that are special or might be unfamiliar to the class. They may also want to talk about the cultural significance of the recipe such as when the dish is eaten or how the dish came to be part of the family.
                Set up the cooking activity at the table during free choice play. This way, children can come and go according to their interests. Remind the children to wash their hands prior to joining the activity. Serve the dish with lunch or afternoon snack. Later that day, dictate a letter from the children. Thank the parent for sharing his or her culture with the class. Include comments from the children about how much they liked the dish and enjoyed the activity.
Variation- Take pictures of the parent and children cooking. Display the photographs on a bulletin board near the sign-in sheet or make a book about the different foods.

Childrens Books:


Celebration Food by Clare Hibbert (2014)

Celebration Food encourages children to think about when they eat special food and what kinds of food they might eat at different celebrations. They will encounter a range of celebrations from around the world, both religious and secular. Finally they can follow the simple recipe to make their own charoset. This book covers a range of celebrations from around the world, both religious and secular, and the foods eaten on those occasions. I would choose this book and read it to the class before we had our first guest come in. It would be a good opener to the kinds of foods you might find in different parts of the world. Many foods parents would most likely bring in would be foods that they make on special occasions or “celebration foods” so I feel like this book would be a great way to get the children thinking about what types of things they might be making!


MAMA PROVI AND THE POT OF RICE by Sylvia Rosa-Casanova

Puerto Rican Mama Provi is famous for her stories and big feasts. And when her granddaughter Lucy is sick, she takes a pot of her signature arroz con pollo (rice and chicken) and starts her climb upward—from the ground floor where she lives to Lucy’s apartment on the eighth floor of a tall building.   Stopping to catch her breath on each floor, she succumbs to the aroma from the apartments. She trades her own dish for a portion of her neighbors’ cuisine and ends up with a large flavorful spread for Lucy. Freshly baked bread from 2B, Senor Rivera’s frijoles Negros, Mrs. Bazzini’s salad, collard greens, Mrs. Woo’s tea and a slice of apple pie from apartment 7C! At the end, we are left satiated, from celebrating diversity through kind neighbors and great food. This book would be awesome to use to show the children that trying new things from different cultures can turn out to be so exciting! I would read this to the children after they were done with their recipe for the week, and were munching on their goodies. This book also shows some amazing character traits such as being giving to one another. Such a good find!

Questions to Answer:

1. Why did you choose this particular activity?
·         I chose this activity because I personally LOVE to cook. I think this is a fabulous way to learn about other children and their families and where they come from! I mean, what better way to teach children about others and their culture than by doing something I love? After looking through all of the activities planned out in the text, the cooking one caught my eye.

2. What is the appropriate age for this activity? 
·         I believe the most appropriate age for this activity is the 5-6 age range. In Roots and Wings, it states that at this age, these children, “understand cultural identity and enjoy exploring.” (York, pg. 21) Of course, any children older than this would be able to participate as well, but 5-6 is when it will be most productive. Children at this age can identify stereotypes, explore real and pretend/fair and unfair, and they are still asking questions and trying to make sense of the world. Children in this age range are, “more group oriented and can begin to understand cultural identity.” (York, pg. 18) 5 and 6 year olds tend to choose friends of the same sex and the same race, which is a good time to do an activity like this to help raise awareness and become a whole as a class. Age 7-9 is also ideal for an activity like this.at this age; these children are very interested in and aware of the world. They want to know what’s going on now, as well as a long time ago. It is CRITICAL that we provide children at this age with accurate information so their understanding becomes different than that of a preschooler- inaccurate and distorted.

3. Explain why this is an appropriate theme.


·         Social-Emotional Development – Hands-on cooking activities help children develop pride and confidence in their skills and abilities. The act of following a recipe can encourage self-direction and independence, while also teaching children to follow directions and use thinking skills to problem solve.
·         Physical Development – Chopping, squeezing, spreading, and mixing are all cooking skills that help develop a child’s small muscle control and eye-hand coordination. It’s impossible to separate hands-on cooking activities from physical development for young children.
·         Cognitive Development – Cooking inspires children’s curiosity, thinking, and problem solving, offering new opportunities to make predictions and observations. Additionally, cooking offers authentic opportunities for students to understand and apply their knowledge of measuring, one-to-one correspondence, numbers, and counting. As they follow a recipe, children organize ingredients, follow a sequence, and carry out multiple directions.
·         Language Development – With its own vocabulary, cooking is a great opportunity for language development. Take advantage of opportunities for children to match pictures to words and articulate questions inspired by their new experiences.
·         Different cultures can be incorporated into each of these reasons why cooking is appropriate for young children, especially 3-8. From learning new words associated with a certain cultures food, to getting the children thinking about other aspects of the child’s culture, multicultural education can easily be incorporated into the activity I have chosen.

4. Goals for Anti-Bias Curriculum:
·     

           Introduce children to other cultures- this activity introduces children to the different foods eaten in different cultures. Each week can be a different kind of food, so the children have a well-rounded idea of the types of foods eaten around the world. They learn to accept differences among classmates and begin exploring similarities and differences in positive ways.
·         Teach children how to cooperate with others- this is shown through working with other children to achieve the same goal, re-create this food dish! Children learn how to cooperate with others best through working through something with other children. They learn how to show empathy for one another and recognize that people can work together to help each other, all while exploring the cultures of the different children in class.
·         Help children to be group members- What better way to learn how to be part of a group than working in small groups?! These children learn how to speak with one another, come up with solutions to potential issues that may arise, and even work together toward a common goal. These children are learning conflict-resolution skills, participating in group problem solving, and even contributing positively inside and outside the classroom.




Conclusion:
           
     In essence, I feel as though this activity would be appropriate and beneficial to children 3-8 years of age. Cooking is a good way to incorporate new cultures and foods into the classroom, as well as teach educational lessons about places all over the world. This activity fits the anti-bias education guidelines and is a good way to teach children life lessons with a fun twist!



    Reference list:

Roots and Wings. Stacey York. 2006

Anti-Bias Education. Louise Derman-Sparks and Julie Olsen Edwards. 2010

"ANTI-BIAS ACTIVITY GOALS” HANDOUT



Sunday, April 12, 2015

Review on the movie Dumbo (1941)



What might children be absorbing from this film?  If you watched the film as a child, what do you remember thinking?  If your children watch this film, what do you think they are learning from it?


This is one Disney movie I never watched as a child, due to my mom not wanting us kids to see it. We never understood why we couldn't watch it, and watching it for the first time as an adult, I now understand. This is a film I wouldn't let my children watch, let alone children in a classroom. There are so many negative messages and stereotypes in this movie; children could get the wrong idea about a lot of things. As we learned earlier, children absorb information at a very young age and tend to keep those views with them throughout their lifetime. Children could be under the impression that racism is okay if it is portrayed in one of their favorite movies. They could feel as though African Americans can only work blue collar, hard labor jobs. Movies such as these could have children of the African American decent thinking they wont be able to get certain jobs. 

Research on this film:

·         “The 1941 classic, Dumbo (which I grew up loving), has a particularly racist foundation. The film is excessively light in its handling of southern racism. The crows are extremely stereo typically black characters. Never mind that the lead crow's name is JIM Crow (that's a whole different article). However, the song "When I See an Elephant Fly," contains heavy-use of southern black vernacular, including: "I'd be done see'n about everything / When I see an elephant fly!" The fact that the crows are the color black and speak in a stereotypical manner could only have reinforced stereotypes. It gets worse. With the "Song of the Roustabouts," Disney features faceless black circus workers working while singing, "We slave until we’re almost dead / We’re happy-hearted roustabout" and "Keep on working / Stop that shirking / Pull that rope, you hairy ape." (Veronica Agard, 2013) 

     " At the beginning of the movie, there is a scene where the circus is being set up. In this scene not only are the animals helping with the work, but also faceless black men are seen setting up. Their faces are completely featureless with no eyes, mouth, or nose. they possess no individual identities at all. This is characteristic of the time period because the 1940's was before the Civil Rights Movement, and although there was no slavery, blacks were still segregated and considered as lesser people at the time." (Alyssa Nelson, 2010)

       " It’s not even subtle racism. It’s overt racism in a Disney film. But I thought Dumbo was a more recent film — turns out it was released in 1941. Ahhhhhhhhh, we all say. That explains why this movie is considered a “classic” instead of 'horrible racist propaganda.'" (Meredith Bland, 2014)

   
     Lyrics to the song the African American workers sang while putting up the circus tent:

     Hike! Ugh! Hike! Ugh! Hike! Ugh! Hike!
We work all day, we work all night
We never learned to read or write
We’re happy-hearted roustabouts
Hike! Ugh! Hike! Ugh! Hike! Ugh! Hike!
When other folks have gone to bed
We slave until we’re almost dead
We’re happy-hearted roustabouts
Hike! Ugh! Hike! Ugh! Hike! Ugh! Hike!
We don’t know when we get our pay
And when we do, we throw our pay away
(When we get our pay, we throw our money all away)
(Song lyrics found by Meredith Bland, 2014)

Crazy that a song like that could be in a CHILDREN'S movie right?!? Hearing a song like that could put the stereotype in a child's head that all African American's are the same. I completely agree with others feelings on this movie: it is blatantly racist. I do understand that being made in 1941, it was around the time when racism was still very common. With that being said, why would this movie be made for children, are those the kinds of messages we want to be sending our children? I mean from the faceless African American men singing about their little pay to the black crow named Jim crow, the racism is pretty obvious throughout the film. Children do not need to be absorbing these messages while watching a movie about a sweet little elephant with big ears. 



Websites:

http://mic.com/articles/68219/6-disney-films-that-are-undeniably-racist-and-sexist

http://disneyandmovies.pbworks.com/w/page/17905679/5%20Dumbo

http://www.mommyish.com/2014/10/10/racist-disney-movies/

Notes taken during movie:

·         Kids believe a stork dropped them off
·         
          Train driver has Spanish accent
·        
          Mrs. Jumbo- momma elephants name
·         
          The other mom elephants nicknamed him Dumbo b/c of his big ears
·         
          We are happy hearted roustabouts- extremely racist!
·         
          African American people putting up tent in rain at night
·        
          Locked mom up in trailer after she was just trying to protect her baby from         the mean kids. Other elephants called “solitary confinement.”
·         
          One elephant said “pretend you don’t see him.”
·         
          Dumbo is always tripping over his ears
·         
          Because he tripped over his ears while running toward their big stunt and           knocked all of the elephants over, he was ridiculed and made into a clown.
·        
         This is a kid’s movie?! The way they treat Dumbo and Mrs. Jumbo is so               wrong. Kids shouldn’t be receiving those messages that that is okay
·        
         Clowns drinking- not a good message
·        
         Clowns portrayed as complete idiots
·        
         Kids could think that drinking bubbles can make you extremely happy and         you can blow bubbles from your mouth. (hallucinating)
·       
        Weird hallucinations…
·        
        Crows are meant to portray African American people- southern accents

Friday, March 13, 2015

Review on: I'm glad I'm a boy! I'm glad I'm a girl! By Whitney Darrow



I'm glad I'm a boy! I'm glad I'm a girl! 

By Whitney Darrow (author and illustrator)

1970

     This book is about what boys like and do compared to what girls like and do. For example, "boys are strong, girls are graceful" and "boys invent things. Girls use what boys invent." 
Just a bit sexist, don't your think? 

      "In 1970, when the second wave of feminism was reaching critical mass and women were raising their voices for equality across the “social media” of the day decades before the internet as we know it, an odd children’s book titled I’m Glad I’m a Boy! I’m Glad I’m a Girl! began appearing in bookstores." (Popova, 2014)

      This book could be interpreted one of two ways: extremely sexist, why would someone create such a book? Or if you do a little research, you find that this author actually wrote very satirical cartoons for the New Yorker for nearly 50 years. We don't know if this book was written in all seriousness or is meant to be satirical. The children in this book, I believe, are portrayed as caricatures. The definition of a caricature is as stated, "a picture, description, or imitation of a person or thing in which certain striking characteristics are exaggerated in order to create a comic or grotesque effect." I feel like this book could be serious, but with Darrow's background, it would make more sense for it to be satirical. Especially because it was published at a time when girls weren't necessarily thankful to be girls in a world of, "outdated cultural expectations." (Popova, 2014)

     These children in the book are very stereo typically portrayed. Boys in general have the power in the story, and girls are very helpless and do things like cooking, cleaning, and work in very woman dominated fields.  They are looked at as not able to do a mans work (such as be the president, policeman, doctors, pilots, etc) Girls act and behave in a certain way, and boys act and behave very opposite. The word choice, "what boys are" as compared to, "what girls are" is very demeaning and causes little boys and girls to think you have a limited about of things you can be when you grow up, toys you can play with, etc. 

     At the time this story was published (1970), women were JUST beginning to shed their gender norms coat, and Darrow was from a time where men and women participated in very different things. This book has nothing to do with any other race but Caucasian men and women. I can only imagine with the demeaning undertones for them, what it would be like for people of color, oh goodness. The narrative and pictures in this book tell us that girls aren't as capable as boys are to do certain things, and that girls should be happy with that. The achievements of girls are minute when compared to what the boys do in this book. The story would turn out completely different if the roles were reversed, and there would be no question that it was meant to be satirical. Boys aren't portrayed in nurturing roles with their families, it is the girls who do the roles associated with having a family. 

Some of the pages that show stereotypes include: 

"boy are Presidents. Girls are First Ladies." 
"Boys are strong. Girls are graceful."
"Boys invent things. Girls use what boys invent." 
"Boys can eat. Girls can cook." 



     It is hard to believe this book could have been written and meant to be funny and ironic. I have a hard time getting past the ridiculous stereotyped portrayed in this book. In the end, after all of the roles are laid out there, it says, "I'm glad you are a boy! I'm glad you are a girl! We need each other."  This is how the story ends and it leaves more questions that resolutions in my mind! Is this really a children's book or is it meant for adults to get a good laugh at? I would never recommend this book for children simply because it sets the standards to what boys and girls can and can't do, and that isn't the case. Boys can do girly things, girls can do things boys do. We are all one and if a boy likes dolls and a girl wants to be a police person, we need to make sure they know that is okay!! We don't want children to think certain labels apply to each gender. 

     The reviews on this book are mixed. Some people don't feel as though it was satire, and others loved it simply because it was funny. 

"I think this book does a horribly great job at showing how far society has moved from this type of thinking when it comes to gender roles." (Mayberry, 2014)



Popova, M. (2014). I'm Glad I'm a Boy! I'm Glad i'm a Girl! Retrieved from http://www.brainpickings.org/2014/01/20/im-glad-im-a-boy-im-glad-im-a-girl-darrow/

Mayberry, E. (2014) Comment retrieved from http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2882044-i-m-glad-i-m-a-boy-i-m-glad-i-m-a-girl